The Consequences of Kinship: Sovereignty, Reason, and the Sick Society

Introduction: The Inevitable Conflict

To step onto the path of the Disciple is to commit an act of rebellion. It is a deliberate severance from the default mode of existence, a rejection of the comfortable drift that characterizes the majority of human life. When one takes the Oath of Discipline, declaring "I am the Disciple of Discipline," they are not merely adopting a new habit; they are fundamentally altering their identity. This alteration comes with consequences. It demands a realignment of values that will inevitably place the practitioner at odds with the world around them.

The philosopher Epictetus, in the ninth chapter of his first book of Discourses, addresses this precise transition. Titled "How from the fact that we are akin to God a man may proceed to the consequences," the discourse lays out the philosophical mechanism for self-mastery. It explains why the decision to live by a code of reason and duty is not just a lifestyle choice, but a recognition of one's true nature. However, this recognition brings friction.

As the Disciple begins to operate by the 8 Realities of the Will, they will encounter resistance, mockery, and isolation. This essay explores the intersection of Epictetus’s ancient wisdom and the Disciple of Discipline (DoD) Codex, illuminating why the path of reason is the only sane response to a profoundly sick society.

Part I: The Dual Nature and the Choice of Identity

Epictetus posits a fundamental duality in the human condition. He states that every human being is a mixture of two elements: the body, which we share with the animals, and reason, which we share with the gods. In the secular framework of the DoD Codex, we interpret "the gods" or "God" not as a theistic deity, but as the Logos—the rational, ordering principle of Nature and the Universe. To be "akin to God" is to possess the capacity for Reason, Volition, and Sovereign Choice.

The conflict arises because, as Epictetus observes, "most of us incline toward this former, wretched kinship". The default human inclination is toward the animalistic side: the body, the appetites, the impulses, and the fear of pain. When a person identifies primarily with their body, they act like a wolf (aggressive), a lion (wild), or a fox (deceitful). Their behavior is dictated by the preservation and comfort of the meat they inhabit.

The DoD Codex addresses this duality through Identity. Reality #8 of the Will states: "Discipline is Identity. It is not an act you perform, but who you are". By taking the Oath, the Disciple actively chooses to identify with the rational, sovereign element of their nature rather than the animalistic one. The Oath states, "I rely on no one to carry my duty. What is mine to do, I must do". This is the voice of Reason asserting dominance over the voice of the "wretched body" that seeks comfort and safety.

This choice is the "consequence" Epictetus speaks of. If you acknowledge that your essential nature is rational and capable of sovereignty, you can no longer permit yourself to think mean or ignoble thoughts about yourself. You cannot accept the narrative of the victim or the consumer. You are compelled by the logic of your own nature to act with dignity. The Disciple does not suppress the body; they simply refuse to let the "animal" drive the chariot.

Part II: Stewardship vs. The Tyranny of the Body

If most of humanity inclines toward the body, they become slaves to it. Epictetus warns that this inclination leads to gluttony and fear. If you believe you are your body, then anything that threatens your body—hunger, cold, fatigue, death—threatens your very existence. You will do anything to avoid discomfort, including betraying your principles.

The DoD Codex refines this relationship through the principle of Stewardship. The Oath declares: "I honor my body, my mind, and my time—not as possessions, but as trusts". This aligns perfectly with Epictetus’s view. We do not reject the body; we manage it. We move from being an "Owner"—who uses the body for pleasure, as the animal does—to a "Steward," who maintains the body as an instrument of the Will.

Reality #3 of the Will states: "Discipline is Stewardship. Your body, mind, and time are not yours to own, but sacred trusts". The consequence of realizing your rational nature is that you treat the body with rigorous care but detached authority. You feed it clean fuel, not because you crave it, but because the machine requires it to serve. You train it in the forge, not for vanity, but to harden it against the drag of the "animal" inclination.

When the Disciple feels the pull of laziness—the "wretched body" calling for rest—they apply the Discomfort Algorithm. They lean into the cold, the final rep, the difficult task. They do this to prove, repeatedly, that the rational mind is the master and the body is the servant. This is the operational consequence of our kinship with Reason.

Part III: The Illusion of Caesar and the Sick Society

Epictetus offers a striking analogy regarding external validation. He notes that in his time, if a man was adopted by Caesar (the Emperor), his arrogance would be unbearable. He would feel safe, powerful, and important because of his proximity to external power. Yet, Epictetus asks, why does being a "son of Zeus" (kin to the rational Universe) not give us the same confidence?

This highlights a profound irrationality in human behavior: we seek security in external status ("Caesar") rather than internal nature ("Zeus"). In the modern world, "Caesar" is society. It is the approval of peers, the accumulation of status symbols, the likes on social media, and the adherence to cultural trends. We feel safe when we are validated by the herd.

The Disciple, however, operates by Reality #1 of the Will: "Discipline is Freedom. True freedom is not the absence of restraint, but the power to govern oneself". The Disciple understands that "Caesar"—the external world—is fickle. To rely on it for safety is to be a slave to it. If your confidence depends on social approval, you are owned by society.

When you take the Oath and begin to live by a code of internal sovereignty, you stop bowing to Caesar. You stop seeking the validation of a culture that is obsessed with comfort and consumption. This withdrawal of consent is noticeable. It is often met with the "external resistance" and "mockery" that are common to the path.

Part IV: The Resistance of the Irrational

The philosopher Jiddu Krishnamurti famously stated, "It is no measure of health to be well adapted to a profoundly sick society." This quote is a diagnostic tool for the Disciple.

When you step onto the path of discipline—waking at dawn, rejecting junk food, refusing to gossip, holding yourself accountable—you are effectively holding up a mirror to those around you. Your discipline highlights their lack of it. Your purpose highlights their drift. The "animal" nature in others will react with hostility because your existence threatens the validity of their comfort.

This resistance manifests as mockery ("Why are you so serious?", "Live a little!"), skepticism ("You can't keep this up"), or outright exclusion. Epictetus would argue that this is the inevitable result of the divergence in natures. Those who identify with the "wretched body" cannot comprehend the motivations of those who identify with Reason. To the herd, the Disciple’s actions appear irrational. Why suffer voluntarily? Why reject pleasure? Why work when no one is watching?

The Disciple understands that the society surrounding them is operating on a disordered hierarchy of values. It prioritizes the short-term over the long-term, the feeling over the fact, and the easy over the right. This is, by definition, irrational. It is a "sick" prioritization.

The "consequence" of the Disciple’s kinship with Reason is the strength to stand apart. The Disciple uses the Master Algorithm: "If faced with any choice... apply the lens of Truth, act with Discipline, and reflect with Humility". They do not seek to adapt to the sickness; they seek to cure it in themselves. They accept that the path of Reason is a lonely one, but they also recognize that "backup never comes". They must be their own validation.

Part V: Citizenship of the World and Secular Transcendence

If the Disciple is separated from the "sick society," does that mean they are isolated? Epictetus answers this with the concept of the Cosmopolis—the idea that we are "citizens of the world".

Because we possess Reason, we are connected to the rational structure of the Universe (Nature). We are not isolated fragments; we are parts of a whole. A foot does not exist for itself; it exists to serve the body. If the foot had reason, it would understand that stepping into the mud or enduring the weight of the body is necessary for the health of the whole.

This is the secular transcendence of the DoD Codex. We do not need a supernatural deity to understand that we are interconnected. We understand the principles of Nature—cause and effect, growth and decay, the ecosystem of humanity.

This realization leads to the Pillar of Service. Reality #6 of the Will states: "Discipline is Service... Its ultimate expression is in service to others". The consequence of our "divine" (rational) nature is that we must serve the whole. We discipline ourselves not for ego, but to be useful to the "Cosmopolis"—our family, our community, our species.

The Oath states: "For my family, for my community... Discipline is my gift of unconditional love". This is the modern application of Epictetus’s citizenship. We bear the burden of discipline so that we can carry the load for those who cannot. We reject the "sick society's" obsession with the self and embrace the rational necessity of cooperation and support.

Conclusion: The Operational Consequence

Epictetus asks, "How from the fact that we are akin to God a man may proceed to the consequences?" The answer, for the Disciple of Discipline, is operational.

The consequence is that we stop identifying as victims of our biology or our circumstances. We reject the "wretched" narrative that we are powerless against our impulses. We accept the Oath of Discipline as a declaration of our rational nature.

The consequence is that we treat our bodies as trusts to be stewarded, not toys to be broken. We utilize the 18 Disciplines to harden the vessel.

The consequence is that we stop fearing "Caesar." We accept the mockery of a sick society as proof that we are on the path of health. We realize that it is irrational to seek directions from people who are lost.

The consequence is that we recognize our citizenship in the greater whole. We bind ourselves to the Pillar of Service, understanding that our strength is only meaningful when it is used to uplift others.

To be a Disciple is to accept these consequences fully. It is to look at the dual nature within—the animal and the reason—and to consciously, daily, and relentlessly choose the side of Reason. It is to walk the "hard path" not as a punishment, but as the only expression of who we truly are.

My writing is deliberately 100% ad-free. I write out of passion and love; for life, for our humanity, for you who reads me. My goal is to create small moments of peace and self-reflection. If you enjoy my work, please consider visiting my tipping jar. Your donations are what make my work possible. Thank you

Questions? Feedback? Have a topic you would like me to address? Send me a DM on Instagram